secular anarchist

75. Finding Common Ground Between Christian and Secular Anarchists with Alan Mosley

About this Episode

Craig is joined by Alan Mosley, the host of “It’s Too Late with Alan Mosley”, historian and libertarian writer, for a friendly discussion about what Alan, an atheist and anarchist, has in common with Christian anarchists. They work through the anarchist catchphrase, “No rulers, no masters, no gods”, exploring its meaning and conclude that Christian and secular anarchists can, and indeed should, be allies in liberty. 

Alan could school some Christians in the teachings of Jesus, especially concerning holding an anti-war stance, the application of the non-aggression principle and disdain for institutional structures. The way Alan sees it, the church has been conquered by the state. Churches fly the American flag and teach the Christian voting block to hate their neighbors and enemies, in direct contrast to the teachings of Jesus. The Bible is full of revolutionary thoughts that, if applied, should transform societies just as they have in the past. 

Craig and Alan discuss everything from dropping bombs to end WWII, support for troops and how to improve their psychological well-being, judging the morality of historical characters from past eras, and things that make the church unappealing to unbelievers. Yet, they continuously come back to the need to speak the truth about all of these things courageously. 

Alan Mosley:

YouTube: It’s Too Late with Alan Mosley

Facebook: It’s Too Late with Alan Mosley

Twitter: It’s Too Late with Alan Mosley

Apple Podcast: It’s Too Late with Alan Mosley

Article: Ike and Leahy Were Right: The Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki Were Wrong

Episode Timestamps:

1:38 – Who is Alan Mosley?

  • Podcast host

  • Jazz musician

  • Historian

  • Writer

3:22 – What common grounds do atheists and Christian anarchists have?

  • Anti-war

    • Not interested in playing politics with war

    • WWII and the atomic bomb

    • Christian anarchists and libertarians are good on this topic

  • The early church were pacifists and anti-war

    • Christians should not defend war

    • Christians should opt out until the government receivess no support for war

  • We need to raise children on principles of non-aggression so they don’t join the military

    • These need to be spoken of rather than ignored

  • Police officers are trained in an us-versus-them mentality

    • Churches teach this way too

    • That was not in the teachings of Christ

  • Supporting the troops is talking about the pressures that face them when they come home

    • High suicide rates

    • Participating in drone bombing pre-schools

    • Improving their psychological well-being

    • Stopping children from entering the recruiting offices

  • Just following orders is not a good excuse

    • It enables the bad ideas of angry rich men in DC to happen


25:27 - The state has conquered churches

  • That’s what the American flag on the stage means

  • The flag is a rival of Christ

  • The state manipulates people through the state

    • Turning you against your neighbor and enemy

    • Making people afraid of the other team

    • Creating a voting block

  • Christians should be suspicious of the state; it killed Jesus

30:14 – Comparing morality through the ages

  • It’s easy to look back and assume moral superiority over the founding fathers over their non-politically correct actions

  • If you look at the state of the world now compared to earlier times, scripture was full of revolutionary ideas

    • Live by the sword, die by the sword

    • Might makes right was the ethos of humanities history

    • The Bible is full of transformational thoughts

    • Christian history is full of people giving their lives to defend their faith

      • But these days, people won’t talk about their beliefs in case they are ostracized

34:55 – What makes the church unattractive to unbelievers?

  • Not representing Jesus correctly

    • Endorsing war and the state

    • Not helping the poor and widows

  • Unequivocal support for Israel’s war atrocities makes the church unappealing

    • Warmongers in Israel don’t care about you even though your taxes pay their way

42:15 – The roots of liberty

  • Anarchy is the root of liberty

    • Christ made everyone with liberty

  • Can anarchists serve Christ?

    • More atheists are statists

    • Alan says no enforced rulers, no enforced masters, no enforced gods

    • True Christians are not for theocratic fascists

    • Adding enforced to the catchphrase makes more sense

  • Bible-thumping church-goers are insufferable

  • Christian anarchists and secular anarchists should be allies in liberty

  • Jesus was the OG anarchist

  • Be charitable in attempting to understand your opponent’s worldview

    • It helps build a community

  • We should not be forced into relationships that we do not want to be a part of either

    • Pick your battles

    • Find the like-minded remnant


Related Episodes

Related Blog Post